Martinez Zogo Murder Trial Latest: several contradictions in Ayissi Nanga’s testimony on Amougou Belinga 0

Lieutenant Colonel Parfait Ayissi Nanga faced questions about inconsistencies in his account of the investigation into journalist Martinez Zogo’s murder during a hearing at the Yaoundé Military Tribunal on November 16, 2026. The prosecution’s 36th witness acknowledged recommending the arrest of businessman Jean-Pierre Amougou Belinga, only to conclude the day after his detention that the evidence did not justify keeping him in custody. He also admitted trying to influence the investigation while accusing Secretary of State for Defense in charge of the Gendarmerie Galax Etoga of improperly interfering in the case.

During the cross-examination, lawyers representing the civil parties, including Joseph Kenmoe and Manyim, along with Claude Assira, who appeared for the state in its capacity as the party bearing civil liability through the Directorate General for External Research (DGRE), confronted the officer with his earlier statements and evidence in the case file. Their questions focused on his relationship with Etoga, his assessment of evidence involving Amougou Belinga and former Bibey mayor Martin Savom, and his reconstruction of the circumstances surrounding Zogo’s death. The exchanges exposed differences between Ayissi Nanga’s criticism of the investigation and actions he acknowledged taking while serving on the joint investigative commission and after his removal. Although he maintained his accusations against several officials involved in the case, the lawyers repeatedly challenged the evidence supporting his conclusions.

From Recommending Amougou Belinga’s Arrest to Supporting His Release Within 24 Hours

One of the first exchanges concerned how Ayissi Nanga joined the joint commission investigating Zogo’s murder. Questioned by lawyer Joseph Kenmoe, the officer insisted that he had not sought a place on the team. “I was not the one who asked to join the investigative commission,” he said.

According to Ayissi Nanga, his involvement began on February 3, 2023, when he visited a senior acquaintance at the Secretariat of State for Defense. The official reportedly told him that the investigation was almost complete, but Lieutenant Colonel Justin Danwe, who was in custody, continued to deny knowing Amougou Belinga. “I then gave my opinion that Amougou Belinga should be arrested, since he was a well-known enemy of the victim,” Ayissi Nanga told the court. The officer subsequently requested permission to meet Danwe, whom he described as a friend and colleague. He said Etoga authorized him to visit Danwe in his cell, hoping the suspect would speak more openly to someone he knew. After the meeting, Ayissi Nanga told Etoga that he did not believe Danwe’s denials about his relationship with Amougou Belinga.

He then recommended arresting the businessman, arguing that the circumstances allowed an arrest without a warrant because the investigation concerned a recent offense. “Amougou Belinga was arrested on the SED’s orders,” he testified, referring to the secretary of state for defense. He added: “It was the SED who brought me onto the commission for the purpose of arresting Amougou Belinga.”

His explanation prompted questions about how quickly his assessment changed. Amougou Belinga was arrested on February 6, 2023, but Ayissi Nanga said the evidence gathered by the following day no longer justified his detention. Assira asked how the officer could recommend an arrest and then support release so soon afterward.

“The assumptions on which I based Amougou Belinga’s arrest were not frivolous,” Ayissi Nanga replied. “But 24 hours later, you asked for his release,” the lawyer countered. Ayissi Nanga maintained that his initial suspicions warranted an arrest but that subsequent checks had failed to produce sufficiently convincing evidence against the businessman. Assira pressed him to explain precisely what evidence had justified those two successive assessments.

Officer Accuses Defense Official of Interference Despite Seeking His Instructions

Ayissi Nanga’s relationship with Galax Etoga formed another major part of the hearing. The officer accused the secretary of state for defense of influencing the investigation in ways he considered incompatible with the authority of the judiciary. “The proceedings were heavily influenced by political power,” he alleged.

To support that accusation, Ayissi Nanga presented WhatsApp conversations with Etoga. At the request of prosecutors and lawyers, the tribunal ordered the messages displayed in court.

But the exchanges raised questions about Ayissi Nanga’s own conduct. According to the messages presented during the hearing, he regularly updated Etoga on the investigation and repeatedly sought instructions from him. As the conversations were displayed, Ayissi Nanga pointed to particular passages. “You can see here that this is interference by the SED in the investigation,” he said.

The lawyers questioned why he had requested instructions from an official whom he now argued had no authority to direct a criminal investigation. Ayissi Nanga explained that he was required to submit daily reports to his superiors. He also cited a July 2001 decree governing the organization of the gendarmerie, which he interpreted as limiting the SED’s authority over judicial proceedings. In his view, the judicial police officers involved in the case answered to the government commissioner, the military judicial authority, for their investigative actions.

Asked why he had nevertheless followed certain instructions, he replied: “Because you cannot openly antagonize an authority who put you on an investigation.”

The exchange highlighted the distinction between a gendarmerie officer’s obligations to his superiors and the authority reserved for judicial officials. The WhatsApp messages establish that Ayissi Nanga and Etoga communicated, but their legal significance depends on the specific instructions given and decisions taken.

Ayissi Nanga also submitted an audio recording that he described as a conversation with Lieutenant Colonel Dieudonné Bialo. He intended to use it to demonstrate that Etoga directly influenced investigators’ decisions.

The recording proved difficult to examine. Several passages were barely intelligible, and the speakers’ voices could not be clearly distinguished. When Ayissi Nanga attempted to explain what was being said, the presiding judge interrupted and instructed him to let the judges listen for themselves. The lawyers then turned to the officer’s activities after his removal from the joint commission on February 12, 2023. Ayissi Nanga acknowledged that he continued investigating and sought information from former colleagues, including Bialo.

Manyim asked why he accused Etoga of interfering in the investigation when he himself had remained actively involved after being removed. “Does my wrongdoing erase the SED’s wrongdoing? You cannot accuse me of interference,” Ayissi Nanga replied. Under further questioning from Assira, he made a more explicit admission. “I influenced the investigation, I acknowledge that. I committed no sin by trying to influence the investigation,” he said.

Ayissi Nanga argued that his own actions were intended to uncover the truth, whereas Etoga’s interventions were improper. The lawyers challenged that distinction by examining what the officer had personally done and which instructions he had accepted.

One Call Involving Savom Versus 27 Between Danwe and Amougou Belinga

The cross-examination also examined how Ayissi Nanga assessed evidence involving different defendants. Throughout his testimony, the lieutenant colonel has maintained that Martin Savom, the former mayor of Bibey, personally killed Martinez Zogo. Under his reconstruction, one group abducted and tortured the journalist before returning him to Yaoundé and handing him over to Savom, who allegedly killed him.

Savom’s defense disputes the accusation, which has not been established by a court ruling. Ayissi Nanga has cited telephone communications between Savom and Zogo to support his theory. He also alleges that investigators attempted to conceal those exchanges by withholding the journalist’s second phone.

Assira compared that reasoning with the communications between Justin Danwe and Amougou Belinga. According to evidence the lawyer discussed in court, the two men exchanged 27 calls between January 16 and 28, 2023. An examination of Danwe’s phone also reportedly uncovered deleted WhatsApp messages between them.

“How can you explain that a single call to Savom was enough to conclude that he was involved and killed Martinez, while 27 calls between Amougou Belinga and Danwe did not raise concerns for us?” Assira asked. Ayissi Nanga responded that the communications between Danwe and Amougou Belinga had other possible explanations. He cited their previous relationship, including an alleged surveillance operation Danwe had conducted against the finance minister on the businessman’s behalf.

“Habits are not evidence. People can meet dozens of times without that constituting a crime,” he argued. He went further: “Danwe and Amougou can meet 1,000 times, but as long as there is no proof that they discussed Martinez’s murder, it is not probative.”

Assira reminded the witness that he had previously invoked the principle of multiple corroborating indications to explain how investigators could build a case without direct evidence. The disagreement centered on the standards Ayissi Nanga applied to different suspects. He considered the communications between Danwe and Amougou Belinga insufficient to establish their involvement in the murder, while treating the exchanges involving Savom as incriminating when combined with his suspicions about the handling of Zogo’s phone.

The circumstances are not identical, however. Ayissi Nanga’s accusation against Savom rests not only on a phone call but also on what he considers irregularities involving the journalist’s second device. Whether those additional allegations provide sufficient support for his conclusion remains disputed.

Two Disputed Phones and Different Standards of Suspicion

The questioning continued with the handling of telephone evidence. Ayissi Nanga claimed that Martinez Zogo’s second phone had been kept at the Secretariat of State for Defense for several weeks before reappearing in the investigation. He alleged that withholding the device prevented investigators from accessing information that would have implicated Martin Savom.

He also claimed the phone had been formatted to erase certain data.

Assira challenged that assertion by citing findings attributed to Bijocka, the expert assigned to examine the device. According to the lawyer, the forensic examination found no evidence that the phone had been formatted.

Ayissi Nanga questioned whether technical expert findings should always be accepted without challenge. During the exchange, however, he presented no technical evidence establishing that the formatting he suspected had occurred. Assira then raised another device: Amougou Belinga’s phone. According to the circumstances described by the lawyer, it had been removed before eventually being recovered in a formatted, unusable condition.

Why, Assira asked, did Ayissi Nanga place so much emphasis on suspected irregularities involving the victim’s phone while appearing less concerned about those affecting the businessman’s device? The officer referred the matter to other commission members, particularly Dieudonné Bialo and Colonel Jean-Pierre Otoulou. “I find it amusing that investigators failed to recover a phone,” he remarked.

Assira reminded him that he had claimed to continue influencing the investigation even after leaving the commission. Had he taken any steps to locate Amougou Belinga’s phone? Ayissi Nanga gave no direct answer. The exchange left unresolved what checks had actually been conducted on the two devices and what evidentiary value any recoverable data might have had.

Murder Reconstruction Challenged by Forensic and Geolocation Evidence

The final series of exchanges focused on the timing of Zogo’s death and the movements of the people Ayissi Nanga implicated in his account. The officer maintained that the journalist was handed over to Martin Savom after being abducted and tortured. He relied in part on a forensic estimate placing the death at least 72 hours before the body was discovered.

Assira challenged that interpretation by referring to other forensic findings discussed in court. According to the lawyer, one report placed the time of death between three and five days before the body was found, a range that also allows for death shortly after the abduction.

“Seventy-two hours or more can mean 72 hours and one second,” Ayissi Nanga replied. The exchange did not resolve the competing interpretations. The forensic time estimates discussed at the hearing do not, by themselves, identify the killer or establish the victim’s movements before death.

Assira then presented geolocation data concerning members of the group involved in the abduction and Martin Savom. According to his analysis, none of the location records cited placed the abductors and the former mayor at the same location at the same time. The absence of matching location data does not necessarily rule out a meeting. But neither does it corroborate Ayissi Nanga’s account of the victim being handed over to Savom.

Assira also questioned the practical circumstances of the movements described by the witness. If the abductors had taken precautions to avoid interception during the kidnapping, how had they transported the victim again, and later his body, without being detected? “Do you know what a cover is? They had a cover vehicle,” Ayissi Nanga replied. Asked for details about that vehicle, the officer provided no information establishing its existence or its role in the alleged movements.

He also raised the possibility that events occurred after 10:40 p.m., while Assira maintained that the geolocation records presented covered a longer period. Several elements of the witness’s reconstruction therefore remain contested: the time of death, the abductors’ movements and the circumstances in which Zogo was allegedly handed over to Savom. None of the geolocation evidence discussed during the exchange materially established that such a transfer occurred.

Accusations Stand Despite Questions About Their Evidence

The lawyers also questioned Ayissi Nanga about his relationships with the officials who led the investigation. He acknowledged that his relations with Galax Etoga, Dieudonné Bialo and Jean-Pierre Otoulou had deteriorated.

Throughout his testimony, the officer repeatedly accused those officials of directing the investigation toward particular conclusions and withholding certain evidence. Some of his criticisms drew approving reactions from Amougou Belinga’s supporters in the courtroom. Assira accused the witness of consistently trying to exclude the businessman from responsibility for the murder.

“You are working relentlessly to exclude Amougou Belinga from this case,” the lawyer told him. “Why are you accusing me of defending Amougou Belinga? What if I told you that you were defending Bialo?” Ayissi Nanga replied. The lieutenant colonel maintained that he had found no evidence establishing Amougou Belinga’s involvement in the killing. He insisted, however, that he had not come to court to declare the businessman innocent, arguing that such a determination belonged to the judges.

At the same time, he claimed to know precisely who participated in the different stages of the crime. The lawyers challenged that certainty, pointing out that several parts of his reconstruction rested on personal deductions whose factual foundations remained disputed.

Asked whether his testimony might have been influenced by his conflicts with senior investigators, Ayissi Nanga said that was for the court to decide. The November 16 cross-examination did not resolve the accusations made by the witness. It did, however, subject his own role in Amougou Belinga’s arrest, his communications with Etoga and the evidence supporting his allegations against Savom to detailed scrutiny. The judges will have to assess those statements alongside the other testimony and evidence in the case.

Source: Sbbc